American Pope Leo XIV Selected by Vatican, Biden's Awkward Interview Discussed

Vatican Makes Historic Choice with American Pope

On May 8, 2025, Megyn Kelly, joined by Josh Holmes, Comfortably Smug, Michael Duncan, and John Ashbrook of the Ruthless podcast, broke the news of a historic moment for the Catholic Church. The Vatican announced the selection of Robert F. Prevost, an American, as the new pope, who has taken the name Leo XIV. This marks the first time an American has been chosen for this sacred role, a decision that carries significant weight for Catholics across the United States and beyond. The panel discussed the dramatic reveal, signaled by white smoke from the Vatican, and the implications of having an American at the helm of the Church during a time of global challenges.

The conversation highlighted Prevost’s background, noting his deep roots in religious service and his journey to this pivotal position. While specific details of his past were not fully explored in the episode, the hosts emphasized the symbolic importance of this selection for American Catholics, viewing it as a moment of pride and a potential shift in the Church’s perspective on various issues.

Biden’s Strained Appearance on The View

Shifting gears around the 15-minute mark, the discussion turned to President Joe Biden and First Lady Jill Biden’s recent sit-down on The View. The panel described the interview as awkward and uncomfortable, pointing out Biden’s questionable remarks regarding the reasons behind Kamala Harris’s loss in the 2024 election. The hosts criticized what they saw as a failed attempt at a 'rehabilitation tour' for Biden, suggesting that his public appearances have done little to restore confidence in his leadership.

Jill Biden’s frequent interruptions during the interview were also a focal point. The panel noted her efforts to defend her husband’s work ethic, despite what they described as evident struggles. At approximately the 20-minute point, Megyn Kelly and her guests delved into Jill’s comments, which hinted at underlying tensions within the Democratic Party. They speculated that her defensiveness might reflect internal frustrations or disagreements, painting a picture of a party grappling with its direction post-election.

Trump’s Surgeon General Pick Sparks Support

At roughly the 30-minute mark, the conversation pivoted to President Donald J. Trump’s selection of Dr. Casey Means as the new Surgeon General. Megyn Kelly expressed strong support for this choice, highlighting Dr. Means’s advocacy for functional medicine, an approach that focuses on addressing the root causes of health issues rather than just treating symptoms. The panel discussed how this pick aligns with a growing interest in alternative health perspectives, emphasizing the potential for Dr. Means to bring fresh ideas to public health policy.

The hosts underscored the importance of having a Surgeon General who prioritizes innovative health strategies, especially in light of ongoing national health challenges. They viewed this appointment as a positive step under President Trump’s administration, reflecting a commitment to rethinking traditional approaches to wellness and medical care.

Congressional Hearing on Sports Policies

Later in the episode, around the 45-minute segment, the discussion touched on a congressional hearing involving Rep. Brandon Gill and Damien Lefeldt, an official from USA Fencing. Rep. Gill’s pointed questioning focused on the contentious issue of men participating in women’s sports. The panel praised Gill’s methodical approach, noting how his line of inquiry exposed what they saw as hypocrisy in Lefeldt’s responses. This segment underscored broader concerns about fairness and policy in athletic competitions, resonating with listeners who value traditional standards in sports.

Reflecting on Key National Issues

Throughout the episode, Megyn Kelly and the Ruthless podcast hosts provided sharp commentary on these diverse topics, weaving together themes of faith, politics, and policy. The selection of Pope Leo XIV was framed as a landmark event, while Biden’s faltering public image was critiqued with a focus on accountability. Trump’s choice of Dr. Casey Means was presented as a forward-thinking move, consistent with efforts to prioritize effective governance. The sports policy debate added another layer, reflecting ongoing cultural discussions that matter deeply to many Americans.

This episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, aired on May 8, 2025, offered a comprehensive look at pressing issues through a lens that values tradition and strong leadership. From the Vatican’s historic decision to domestic political missteps and promising administrative appointments, the conversation captured a snapshot of a nation navigating complex times with an eye toward enduring principles.