News
Congressional Hearing Targets Sanctuary Policies
On March 5, 2025, Republicans in Congress intensified their focus on four American cities—New York, Chicago, Denver, and Boston—labeled as the nation’s worst offenders for their sanctuary policies. This push comes as President Donald J. Trump accelerates his administration’s mass deportation campaign, a cornerstone of his second term that began January 20, 2025. The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform has summoned the mayors of these cities—Eric Adams, Brandon Johnson, Mike Johnston, and Michelle Wu—for a hearing on March 6, aimed at dismantling what GOP leaders call a dangerous impediment to federal immigration enforcement.
House Speaker Mike Johnson, leading the charge, declared, ‘These cities have rolled out the red carpet for illegal aliens while thumbing their noses at federal law.’ The hearing follows Trump’s March 4 address to Congress, where he vowed to secure the southern border and deport millions, citing national security and economic stability as top priorities. With a Republican-controlled Congress, the administration sees these sanctuary cities as prime targets in its quest to restore order and uphold the rule of law.
Trump Administration’s Aggressive Stance
The Trump administration wasted no time targeting sanctuary policies, filing lawsuits against Chicago, Illinois, and New York state within its first month. Border Czar Tom Homan, a key figure in Trump’s immigration strategy, has threatened decisive action, famously promising to bring ‘hell’ to Boston after clashing with its police commissioner. ‘We’re not playing games,’ Homan stated on February 28, 2025, during a press briefing. ‘These cities are harboring criminals, and we’ll root them out.’
This rhetoric aligns with Trump’s broader deportation agenda, which includes deploying military assets like the 3,000 troops sent to the southern border on March 1. The administration blames sanctuary cities for obstructing Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), which relies on local cooperation to execute large-scale deportations. By refusing to notify ICE of illegal immigrants in custody or hold them for federal pickup, these cities have drawn the ire of a White House determined to deliver on its campaign promises.
New York: A Flashpoint of Resistance
New York City, under Mayor Eric Adams, stands out as a major battleground. Its policies, rooted in a 1989 executive order and reinforced by subsequent laws, prohibit city employees from assisting ICE unless public safety is directly threatened. In 2024 alone, New York processed over 100,000 migrants bussed from Texas, straining resources and prompting Adams to seek federal aid—yet he has maintained the city’s sanctuary status. Republicans point to cases like the release of a migrant accused of assault in January 2025, who evaded ICE, as evidence of a broken system.
The administration’s lawsuit against New York state, filed February 15, 2025, targets laws barring ICE from courthouses and limiting data sharing. GOP lawmakers argue this shields dangerous individuals, with Rep. Jim Jordan asserting, ‘New York’s coddling of illegals puts Americans at risk.’ The hearing will likely grill Adams on these policies, especially as deportations from New York ramp up, with over 2,000 removed since January using military aircraft from Stewart Air Base.
Chicago’s Longstanding Sanctuary Defiance
Chicago, the nation’s third-largest city, boasts some of the strongest sanctuary protections, dating back to the 1980s. Its Welcoming City Ordinance, enacted in 2012 and bolstered in 2017 and 2020, bars police and city workers from aiding ICE, even requiring documentation of federal requests. Mayor Brandon Johnson, who took office in 2023, inherited a migrant surge that saw 15,000 asylum-seekers housed in police stations and airports at its peak. Though arrivals have since declined, Johnson defends the city’s stance, claiming it protects community trust.
Republicans see Chicago as a symbol of lawlessness, citing a February 2025 ICE report that 300 detainees with criminal records were released due to non-cooperation. The administration’s lawsuit against Illinois, filed February 10, challenges state laws allowing driver’s licenses for illegal immigrants, which GOP leaders say facilitates their evasion of federal authorities. ‘Chicago’s a magnet for chaos,’ Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene said on March 3, setting the stage for a contentious hearing.
Denver’s Migrant Surge Fuels GOP Criticism
Denver, under Mayor Mike Johnston, has emerged as a sanctuary hotspot after absorbing over 40,000 migrants since 2022, many redirected from Texas. The city’s 2017 ordinance limits cooperation with ICE, and Johnston has resisted federal pressure, even as local resources buckled under a $180 million cost in 2024 alone. Republicans highlight Denver’s release of a migrant charged with drug trafficking in January 2025, who later fled, as proof of sanctuary policies’ failures.
The GOP accuses Denver of prioritizing illegal immigrants over citizens, with Sen. Ted Cruz calling it ‘a slap in the face to hardworking Americans.’ The March 6 hearing will press Johnston on why Denver continues to shield what the administration deems a growing criminal element, especially as Trump’s deportation flights—over 1,500 from Colorado since January—gain momentum. The Pentagon’s border troop surge is seen as a complementary effort to choke off such migrant flows at their source.
Boston’s Clash with Federal Authority
Boston’s sanctuary status, codified in its Trust Act, restricts police cooperation with ICE except in cases like human trafficking. A 2017 Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruling further bars local authorities from detaining individuals solely for ICE. Mayor Michelle Wu, facing reelection in 2025, has clashed with Homan, calling his threats ‘insulting’ and vowing to keep Boston a safe haven. Suffolk County DA Kevin Hayden backs her, arguing cooperation undermines crime-solving by scaring off immigrant witnesses.
Republicans counter that Boston’s policies endanger public safety, pointing to a March 2, 2025, ICE operation thwarted when local police refused to assist, allowing a suspect with gang ties to vanish. ‘Boston’s playing roulette with American lives,’ Rep. Matt Gaetz warned. The hearing will spotlight this standoff, with Homan expected to testify on the need to override such local defiance to achieve Trump’s deportation goals.
A Unified GOP Push for Accountability
With Vice President JD Vance and a GOP Congress in lockstep, the administration views these four cities as test cases for dismantling sanctuary policies nationwide. The Oversight Committee, chaired by Rep. James Comer, plans to expose what it calls a ‘web of lawlessness,’ leveraging the hearing to pressure mayors into compliance. Legislative proposals, including a $4.5 trillion package with border security funds, aim to penalize non-compliant cities by withholding federal dollars—a tactic Trump employed in his first term.
The administration’s early deportation tally—over 5,000 since January—signals its resolve, backed by military logistics and a Justice Department task force targeting cartels. Republicans argue these cities’ resistance only delays the inevitable, with Johnson asserting, ‘We’ve got the votes and the will to fix this.’ As the March 6 showdown looms, the GOP is betting that public support for Trump’s hardline stance will force these sanctuary strongholds to bend.